Peer Review Policy
Journal of Advances in Clinical and Biomedical Research (JACBR) is committed to maintaining the quality, integrity, transparency, and scientific validity of the research it publishes. Manuscripts submitted to the journal are evaluated through editorial assessment and independent peer review.
1. Peer Review Model
JACBR operates a double-anonymous peer review process. During the review process, the identities of the authors are concealed from the reviewers, and the identities of the reviewers are concealed from the authors.
Authors are therefore expected to prepare manuscripts in a manner that does not unnecessarily reveal their identity in the anonymized manuscript file.
2. Initial Editorial Assessment
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial assessment by the editorial office or an appropriate editor.
At this stage, the manuscript may be evaluated for:
- relevance to the aims and scope of JACBR;
- compliance with the journal's submission requirements;
- originality and scientific relevance;
- basic methodological adequacy;
- ethical compliance;
- quality and completeness of the manuscript;
- plagiarism, inappropriate duplication, or other publication-integrity concerns.
A manuscript that is clearly outside the journal's scope, seriously deficient, or inconsistent with the journal's ethical or editorial requirements may be rejected without external peer review.
3. Selection of Reviewers
Manuscripts that pass the initial assessment are normally sent to at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise.
Reviewers should not have conflicts of interest that could compromise their impartiality. The editorial team may select additional reviewers when further specialist assessment is required.
4. Reviewer Evaluation
Reviewers may be asked to assess:
- originality and scientific significance;
- appropriateness of the research design and methodology;
- reliability and interpretation of the results;
- adequacy of statistical analysis, where applicable;
- clarity and completeness of presentation;
- relevance of tables, figures, and supplementary materials;
- adequacy and relevance of references;
- compliance with ethical and reporting requirements;
- whether the conclusions are supported by the evidence presented.
Reviewers are expected to provide constructive, evidence-based, and professional comments.
5. Confidentiality
Submitted manuscripts and peer-review materials are treated as confidential documents.
Reviewers must not disclose, distribute, reproduce, or use unpublished information obtained through the review process for personal, academic, professional, or commercial advantage.
Editors are also responsible for protecting the confidentiality of manuscripts and reviewer information.
6. Conflicts of Interest
Editors and reviewers must disclose any financial, professional, institutional, personal, academic, or other conflict of interest that could affect, or reasonably appear to affect, their objectivity.
A reviewer who believes that a conflict prevents an impartial assessment should decline the review.
7. Editorial Decisions
Following peer review, an editorial decision may include:
- Accept
- Revisions Required
- Resubmit for Review
- Decline Submission
The final publication decision is made by the responsible editor based on the manuscript, reviewers' reports, authors' responses, journal policies, and relevant ethical and scientific considerations.
Reviewer recommendations inform but do not independently determine the final editorial decision.
8. Revision of Manuscripts
When revisions are requested, authors should carefully address the reviewers' and editors' comments and provide a clear response describing the changes made.
Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or evaluated by the editor, depending on the extent and nature of the revisions.
More than one round of revision may be required.
9. Reviewer Disagreement
When reviewers provide substantially conflicting assessments, the editor may evaluate the arguments, request clarification, invite an additional independent reviewer, or take other appropriate editorial steps before making a decision.
10. Research and Publication Ethics
For research involving human participants, patient information, human biological materials, animals, clinical interventions, or other ethically sensitive research, editors and reviewers may examine whether appropriate ethical requirements have been met.
The journal may request ethics committee approval information, informed-consent documentation, trial-registration information, underlying data, or other supporting documentation when necessary.
11. Reviewer Conduct
Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts objectively and respectfully. Personal criticism, discriminatory comments, misuse of confidential information, and attempts to improperly influence authors or editorial decisions are unacceptable.
Reviewers should identify relevant published work that may have been overlooked and should alert the editor to suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data manipulation, ethical concerns, or other potential research-integrity problems.
12. Use of Artificial Intelligence in Peer Review
Reviewers and editors remain responsible for their assessments and decisions.
Confidential or unpublished manuscript material should not be uploaded to external artificial intelligence systems when doing so could compromise confidentiality, intellectual property, personal data, or other protected information.
AI-generated output must not replace the reviewer's independent scholarly judgment.
13. Editorial Independence
Editorial decisions are based on scientific merit, methodological quality, relevance to the journal, ethical compliance, and the evidence available to the editors.
Commercial considerations, author fees, sponsorship, advertising, or other inappropriate external interests must not determine whether a manuscript is accepted or rejected.
14. Appeals and Complaints
Authors may contact the editorial office if they believe that a significant procedural or factual error affected an editorial decision.
An appeal should provide a clear and reasoned explanation. Submission of an appeal does not guarantee that the original decision will be changed.
